In the heart of Cobble Hill, one of Brooklyn’s most architecturally rich neighborhoods, stands a remarkable example of adaptive reuse architecture: The Arches at Cobble Hill. Designed and transformed by Scarano Architect, PLLC, this award-winning condominium conversion demonstrates how historic preservation and modern residential design can coexist to strengthen both community identity and urban living.
Originally built in 1858 as St. Peter’s Church, along with its rectory and nursing academy, the property at 401 Hicks Street was reimagined into a luxury residential development while preserving the integrity of its historic Gothic architecture. The project is widely regarded as one of Brooklyn’s standout examples of adaptive reuse, a growing architectural trend that focuses on repurposing historic structures for contemporary use rather than demolishing them.
Scarano Architect, PLLC, approached the conversion with a deep respect for the building’s historic character. Rather than erase the past, the firm incorporated original architectural elements into the new residential design. Historic stained-glass windows, exposed wood trusses, soaring ceilings, arched openings, carved stone detailing, and original masonry were carefully preserved and integrated into the modern living spaces, creating residences that feel both timeless and contemporary.
The redevelopment transformed the landmarked complex into fifty-nine luxury condominium residences while maintaining the dramatic visual identity of the original church campus. One of the project’s most talked-about features is the dramatic bell-tower duplex, complete with a 30-foot atrium that highlights the scale and grandeur of the original ecclesiastical architecture. Throughout the property, residents experience architectural details rarely found in new construction, including cathedral-height ceilings, oversized Gothic windows, and handcrafted historic materials that connect the building to Brooklyn’s nineteenth-century past.
What makes The Arches particularly important from an architectural perspective is the way the project balances preservation with innovation. Adaptive reuse projects often present significant technical and structural challenges, especially when converting historic religious buildings into residential spaces. Scarano Architect, PLLC, successfully addressed these challenges by modernizing the interiors for contemporary living while retaining the building’s historic elements. Mechanical systems, structural reinforcements, residential layouts, and modern amenities were seamlessly integrated into the existing framework without compromising the architectural integrity of the original design.
The project also highlights the increasing importance of sustainable architecture and environmentally responsible development in urban environments. Reusing an existing building significantly reduces demolition waste and conserves the embodied energy already present in the structure’s materials. In many ways, adaptive reuse is one of the most sustainable forms of architecture because it extends the life cycle of historic buildings while minimizing the environmental impact associated with entirely new construction. The Arches at Cobble Hill stands as an example of how preservation and sustainability can work hand in hand.
Today, The Arches remains highly sought after in the Brooklyn luxury real estate market because it offers something increasingly rare in modern development: authentic architectural character. In an era where many residential buildings can feel repetitive or overly standardized, The Arches delivers individuality, craftsmanship, and a powerful sense of place. Buyers continue to be drawn to the building’s unique layouts, dramatic interior volumes, landscaped courtyard spaces, and preserved prewar detailing.
The development also contributed to the continued revitalization and desirability of the Cobble Hill neighborhood. Known for its tree-lined streets, historic brownstones, and proximity to Manhattan, Cobble Hill has become one of Brooklyn’s most desirable residential communities. Projects like The Arches helped demonstrate that historic preservation could play a significant role in neighborhood growth and economic development without sacrificing architectural authenticity or community character.
For Scarano Architect, PLLC, the project reinforced the firm’s reputation for innovative residential architecture, landmark restoration, and complex adaptive reuse developments throughout New York City. Over the years, the firm has become recognized for finding creative ways to revitalize older structures, while respecting the history and context of the surrounding neighborhood. The Arches remains one of the firm’s signature projects because it exemplifies how thoughtful design can transform historic buildings into vibrant modern spaces without losing their original identity.
More than two decades after its conversion, The Arches at Cobble Hill continues to serve as a benchmark for adaptive reuse architecture in Brooklyn and beyond. The project illustrates how thoughtful architectural intervention can breathe new life into historic buildings while preserving the stories embedded in their walls. In a city constantly evolving through development and reinvention, The Arches proves that preservation and progress do not have to exist in opposition-they can work together to create architecture with lasting cultural, environmental, and economic value.
Please visit our website to learn more about our award-winning projects.